Outerwear guide
Wet is the problem, not cold
A British winter rarely gets cold enough to need a serious coat. It gets wet enough, for long enough, that the wrong one is miserable. Three materials answer that differently and all three publish the number that gives them away.
The number that separates one waterproof from another
Hydrostatic head is how far a column of water can stand on a fabric before it comes through, measured in millimetres, and it is the one waterproofing figure makers print. It is worth knowing the range before you read a label: among the coats here, one jacket publishes 20,000mm and another publishes 10,000mm. Both are honestly waterproof, and one of them is twice the other.
For a British winter the practical line is lower than the marketing suggests. Sustained rain and wind is what 10,000mm handles; 20,000mm is for staying out in it all day. What actually ruins a coat before either number does is the stitching, because every seam is a row of holes. A jacket that states its hydrostatic head and says nothing about taped seams has told you the easy half.
- Finisterre publish a hydrostatic head figure as a headline specification. Finisterre
- Montane publish the same figure for their membrane, at half the number. Montane
- A waterproof is only as good as its seams, and Finisterre state theirs are taped. Finisterre
Down is the warmest thing here and the worst when it is wet
Fill power measures loft rather than quantity: how much space an ounce of down occupies, and therefore how much air it traps. Higher is warmer for the weight, and it is a specification worth reading because it does not track price. The £700 Conduit is filled with 1000 fill down. The £1,600 Sorin, from the same maker, is 850.
The more useful thing is what makers do about down getting wet, because wet down collapses and stops insulating. There are two honest answers and both are on the page. Arc'teryx put synthetic insulation into the parts of the Sorin most likely to get damp, which is a down jacket whose own maker does not trust down everywhere on it. Berghaus instead treat the down so it resists water. Neither is a fudge; both are an admission of the same weakness.
Synthetic buys you the wet day, not the cold one
Synthetic fill is heavier and bulkier than down for the same warmth, and Montane describe theirs as imitating the loft of down rather than bettering it. What it adds is behaviour when soaked: it keeps some loft and it dries quickly. In a climate where the coat spends five months damp rather than two weeks frozen, that is usually the trade worth making, and it is why the synthetic jackets here, which sit around a fifth of what the best down costs, are a more sensible British purchase than their price suggests.
- Montane describe their synthetic fill as imitating what down does, and as drying fast. Montane
Wax is the only one you can renew
Waxed cotton is the least technical answer and the only one that gets better rather than worse. It is water resistant rather than waterproof, so it loses to a membrane in sustained rain, and it is heavy. What it has is a maintenance path: the wax is a consumable you reapply, and the cloth underneath is just cotton, so the garment is repairable in a way a bonded membrane is not. Private White name the mill and the cloth weight and sell the coat with a lifetime repair service.
That is the real decision in this category and it is not about weather at all. A membrane jacket is a ten year object that eventually delaminates and is thrown away. A wax jacket is a thirty year object that needs an afternoon every other winter. Buy the one that matches how you would rather spend the time.
- Private White state the cloth, its weight and the mill it came from. Private White V.C.
- They sell the jacket with a repair service attached to it. Private White V.C.
Researched 2026-11-06. Prices are what the retailer asked on that date.